Posted on
March 19, 2010 by
Mookie
I often read really good articles about baseball, and like to share them when they are Twins related. This story, written by a Yankee fan, offers some perspective on why baseball would be tainted if Mauer ended up a Yank for economic reasons. Every day that passes, where Mauer’s contract has not been extended, is a day closer to baseball doomsday.
Here is the article:
Published March 18, 2010 by:
Ron Hart
The Minnesota Twins and their homegrown native son Joe Mauer, who may someday be considered the greatest catcher of all time, are reportedly having trouble agreeing to a contract extension.
As the Twins are just about ready to open a brand new modern stadium, Target Field, and as they come off yet another successful season on a smallish payroll, this should be a great time for the Twins and their fans. The Twins have been the model franchise on how to compete in the big leagues in a small market and Target Field, as a baseball only stadium with all of the modern amenities, is drawing rave previews.
But it appears the Opening Day pageantry may have a shadow hanging over it as the uncertainy over the Mauer contract situation promises to become more of a distraction.
As is becoming par for the course in baseball, the New York Yankees and Boston Red Sox are increasingly being mentioned as possible suitors for Mauer. The Yankees still have a very productive and borderline Hall of Fame caliber catcher in Jorge Posada. While the Red Sox do not have a top line catcher, the combination of Victor Martinez and Jason Variteck is something most teams would happily sign up for.
Recent days have seen speculation in the New York newspapers that the Yankees, who happen to have the top catching prospect in the game in Jesus Montero, could trade him and other prospects for Mauer. The way it works in modern baseball, if a team believes it cannot afford a free agent to be, they will trade him a year or two prior to his contract expiring so that they can at least get some inexpsensive talent in return.
While I am personally a big time Yankees fan and have been since birth, I am rooting very hard for Joe Mauer to stay in Minnesota. Free agency is a fact of life in baseball, as are economic realities. But Joe Mauer grew up near the Twin Cities and as a Twins fan.
The Twins fans have supported their team even when it had a difficult time competing on a lesser payroll. This is not a franchise that has a bunch of bandwagon fans, or one that shows up only when it’s ‘trendy’. And
while the city is far smaller, I’d venture to say that there are per capita far more ‘real Twins fans’ in the Minneapolis St. Paul area than there are ‘real Dodgers fans’ in LA. And while the Twins will never reach the glamour level that the Dodgers do, they represent the type of fan base that is critical to the health of Major League Baseball and the sport itself.
I have another reason, perhaps one more selfish, for wanting Joe Mauer to remain a Minnesota Twin. If Mauer is traded to the Yankees, or signs with them in the offseason, then it really will confirm all the worst that people say about baseball and the Yankees.
When I defend the Yankees and their payroll to people, I point out that while the Yankees spend a lot of money, they do so mainly to keep their own homegrown players in the fold. The Yankees have had through the past fifteen years more homegrown stars than any team in baseball. Derek Jeter, Mariano Rivera, Jorge Posada, Bernie Williams, Andy Pettitte, and Robinson Cano are all home grown Yankees making large salaries. Yes, Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira and CC Sabathia are big time, expensive free agents (though technically, the Yankees acquired A-Rod through a trade), but it’s not as if most of the team was simply bought.
But bringing Joe Mauer in would confirm the worst and make it difficult, even for me, to defend it anymore.
Plus, the reality is that as a fan you want to have something to root for. Nobody’s favorite basketball team was the Harlem Globetrotters. And while the randomness and vagaries of baseball are far too great for payroll alone to guarantee anything, what fun is it rooting for a team with a mega-star at every position…unless, of course, they were your own homegrown megastars?
So for the good of non-Yankee fans everywhere, please let’s have Joe Mauer stay a Minnesota Twin. And for the good of Yankee fans everywhere, please let’s have Joe Mauer stay a Minnesota Twin.